top of page

Settlement in New Iceland – Selkirk, Hecla, and Fishing on Lake Winnipeg

By Gerry Stefanson


Gerry Stefanson is a member of the Icelandic Roots Author’s Group, and we are pleased to share his musings through poetry, a craft he has honed in more recent years. Many of Gerry’s poems have been previously published in our Newsletters. He has also published poet “Chap Books” through Spillwords. You can see more of his work, including Passages and Bouleversant HERE.


For June, we are profiling the New Iceland area on Lake Winnipeg, Manitoba as part of our North American settlement series. In this article, Gerry addresses his Icelandic heritage and growing up in Selkirk, Manitoba.


This article combines two narrative elements: First, in prose, Gerry tells us "what he knows" and "what he doesn’t know" and the "why" when it comes to presenting the history of the area and that of his Icelandic family. Then he captures that history in a series of sagas, but in poetry form.


From Gerry:   

 


Things we Know – Things we Don’t Know – Things We Don’t Know We Don’t Know



Gerry Stefanson
Gerry Stefanson

I picked this title as I have put myself in The Pickle Jar, really. I belong to the Writing Group with Icelandic Roots; I am a poet for them and with them. This is a good thing for me, as I’m of double-sided Icelandic dissent. My name, Gerald Walter Stefanson, respects both sides of the family: Walter from my mom’s side as she was a Walterson, and Stefansson is the family name from my father’s side.


Selkirk Manitoba is where I was born and raised, as were my parents (to the best of my knowledge). This is mentioned as my father passed over in 1974 at 63, and my mother departed 20 years later. Dad knew all family matters on both sides.


These things I know well.


Missing them dearly, I am wishing I now had his advice, help and knowledge. I’m learning much about here-say and rumour, and to research deeper and ask questions. My siblings, Ken and Myrna, have also departed, so being the youngest in the family doesn’t grant me poetic license, but possibly a little wiggle room. All my aunts and uncles have crossed the Norse Rainbow bridge, so my ‘A’ line of those who have thinned out leaves me reaching out to cousins, contacts, and old neighbors to connect the dots.


Again – things we don’t know, but we know we don’t know.


I do know in a moment when “I should know better.” I offered to write on Icelanders in and about The Big Island or Hecla Island, Icelanders in and from Selkirk, and fishing in general on Lake Winnipeg for Icelandic Roots. On reflection, all that is a vast subject, hence –


Things we don’t know, we don’t know.


Now this as where this gets tricky – you know. So, to quote my dad’s favorite poet Robert Service “a promise made is a debt unpaid.”


Ah – poetry I love, storytelling I love. The common denominator that makes story telling a little awkward is that I am blessed with being dyslexic, which holds an advantage for poetry but a challenge for story writing. Note: I failed a grade eleven math exam on my interpretation or creative spelling. Poet’s note: over 40ish spelling mistakes so far, a sprinkling of grammatic "oops" and only three scoops of my loving wife’s advice so far.


I have solicited that, in Icelandic tradition, I will write these five tales as a series of Saga’s. Maybe a highbred Prose Poem or, Haibun, closing with appropriate Haiku.



SAGA 1: WESTLANDER The first in a series of five sagas on the settlement in New Iceland area of Manitoba.

 

Arriving on Willow Island, October 1875. (Photo sourced from Icelandic Roots images. Original painting by the late Arni Sigurdson.)
Arriving on Willow Island, October 1875. (Photo sourced from Icelandic Roots images. Original painting by the late Arni Sigurdson.)

  arriving in 1875 New Icelanders to this land came

Iceland to the new Kanada, land of promise, of land

Keewatin yet Manitoba to be, 200 in their claim

Sir John A. shook hands with Mr. Jonas, deal done.

lake to fish, winter would freeze

land to farm yet held snake and mosquito

new ways to fish, new way to farm, smallpox disease

first nation & Meti taught them both, convenient harmony.

many new lessons to know, learn, fish, sow

home to build, coffee to drink all require money

schools, churches, add up to never let low

yet the Dakotas call Mountain some folk to go.

wagons, dreams, hopes Icelandic River to Riverton became

Hecla, Alborg then Selkirk claimed too

land of opportunity grew, then a train

pulling together, so much done and yet do.

dottir and son added – dottirs and sons

Althing idea leads to woman vote overdue

education, schools, papers of news, bums in pews

fishermen, farmers, writers, social, clergy, politic views

Doctors, Falcons to the front flew.

this Saga never stops – all knew where they’re from

knowing where they would go

West they went West.

                                        STOP

                                      when there

                                     becomes here



SAGA 2: Stepping Stone at WEST The second in a series of five sagas on the settlement in New Iceland area of Manitoba.


Hecla Church and Cemetery (May 2025). Photo shared with permission.
Hecla Church and Cemetery (May 2025). Photo shared with permission.

there it was, small stone all alone, one name

there father pointed, I only recall, JONAS

there is your name from whence you came

upper northwest corner Hecla Island 2nd cemetery

he wanted me to know, see, understand – believe

pass it down /pass it on

Big Island / *Hekla Icelandic samed

this seam re-ties the thread of our lives

partonic naming not in my head or compass

now Finn er Finnson er pass coming forward

with other monikers, Jonas (my people)

an answer me not with knowledge of question

oldest living Icelander was a forefather

my father with the key in hand

me searching for a lock.

as father, I brought my children to same stone

now attempt turn into a known path.

Hekla Iceland’s renounced volcano

barks & roars – heard round the world

think 2010, shuttering all

Christians thought gateway to hell Hekla

Pagan Hearts knew Norse after world was freezing/frozen well

the world knows and lesson’s its ferocity – respect its heritage

New Icelanders – picked a strong name from their past to claim a mark

for a Kanada start

start they did and spread WEST.

 

What the Deuce is an Islendingadagurinn

Where could they reside, spoken as a non-goolie point of view.

They are Icelandic summer fest Deuce in North Dakota

Islendingadagurinn in Gimli oh so close to Hecla Island

On Lake Winnipeg North of Selkirk, a brisk walk above Lower Fort Gary

Whew, get a map. Lots of history – flash back Lord Selkirk, settlers earlier 1800’s

Seven Oaks Massacre, Upper Fort Gary, Norway House (N. Lake Wpg), Louis Riel,

Royal Northwest Mounted Police, Battle of Duck Lake, Doomed Dumont, executed

Louis. Fast forward, Icelanders made it work!

Roll this all up equals Manitoba, Mountain the Dakotas not without adventure.

Icelanders get a new cut of the cards. Yet they made it work there, across Canada, USA,

numbers say/show they came to say/stay.

Think – marsh to farm, a lake that freezes over, mosquitoes, snakes (Man. Garter snake

capital of the world) winter deep winter, summer hotter than the hubs of Hell.

New world. New lives. All memories now so far East their so West.


                                                            fulfilled now                                                         empty promise                                                          that was kept         


  

SAGA 3:  Baited the Hook to Immigrate The third in a series of five sagas on the settlement in New Iceland area of Manitoba. 


Harvesting near Riverton, (1890). Image sourced from Manitoba Historical Society - Archives of Manitoba
Harvesting near Riverton, (1890). Image sourced from Manitoba Historical Society - Archives of Manitoba

 


A freight gang hauling fish to Riverton (1920). Image sourced from Manitoba Historical Society - Archives of Manitoba
A freight gang hauling fish to Riverton (1920). Image sourced from Manitoba Historical Society - Archives of Manitoba













fish ‘n farmland, in new land

landed papered, owned future hope

crops to grow/grow from dreams/to own land

Away from cranky Volcano

perhaps nasty neighbour

Hymns of song new

We yearn to learn

we rose to the bait

maybe cast by the Fate’s

and fish to feed, little restriction, open water

pull magnated to free men everywhere, siren’s call west

come west, fish farm and sow sweet land

as their ancestor’s answered a millennium past, west

yet much to learn, a lake that froze, land that flooded

cursed Smallpox that found them

found the Skraeling* and Metis

suffering loss, futures now shared

guided us the new by them who know

Icelander knew of Skraeling from Saga’s

Now lived with them

They taught them the ways of west lake fish

They caught them through water

They brought them to pull via ice

They dragged them through Pox

Farming a new game too

This was marshy, floodish, new crop

New ways, new everything this west

Pickerel, lake trout, bull head, sauger, bass

Not cod nay salmon as back East

Yet big sea, shallow lakes both feed on men.

So so much to leanlearn.

So so much to leaveleft

Then came grasshoppers

The all new west.

               

* Skraeling or skraelings was used by the Norse, in particular the Vikings, in reference to the indigenous peoples they encountered when exploring North America in the year 1000 AD.


SAGA 4: Community Clan-Ish Core Chores The fourth in a series of five sagas on the settlement in New Iceland area of Manitoba.


Settlement cabin display at the New Iceland Heritage Museum, Gimli MB. Photo used with permission.
Settlement cabin display at the New Iceland Heritage Museum, Gimli MB. Photo used with permission.

a Viking somewhere, some time

gave way to a forever rhyme

did travel to Ethiopia for bean

where they come across cathine

who knows I don’t, the why are still

obvious now it’s here

every New Iceland home had rarities

even with disparities

was a sad house that didn’t offer coffee

was a sad house without books

was a community without library/school

church shortly had a place

or were placed everywhere

Selkirk Evangelical Icelandic Lutheran

Where my so-called teeth were cut

even hints of ‘sight’, hidden folk

13 Christmas elves, Freya’s cats, who now shares

Odin’s hat

so, around a millennial back Icelanders in Mass converted

hark King Olaf’s Host swords sing “was a miracle”

Icelandic Althing hums softly

not to bend a knee.

tales tall tell even churches

can do the splits

as congregations do what fits

Odin but true, that is what most religions due

new world west, leads to new times.

those “are not nice woman” helped lead

parades, speeches, parliament floors

Manitoba heard the

ring at all the doors

votes for who/yes woman too.

then back to Iceland in 1975

the ladies strike hard strived

these for equity rights

within a decade a Shieldmaiden

became 1st Female president international

the blood holds true, law keepers’ peoples again fashionable.

a country without a king

a true a proper a true thing

Democracy for the people.


SAGA 5: FISHING The LAKE The SELKIRK TAKE The fifth in a series of five sagas on the settlement in New Iceland area of Manitoba. 


The Suzanne E, a fishing vessel on Lake Winnipeg. This 70-tonne freighter sank off Grindstone Island after encountering harsh weather in September 1965. Image sourced from CBC Manitoba.
The Suzanne E, a fishing vessel on Lake Winnipeg. This 70-tonne freighter sank off Grindstone Island after encountering harsh weather in September 1965. Image sourced from CBC Manitoba.

 

The fish were in the lake        – check

The market was in WPG.        – check

The Rapids were in between – check

The docks were in Selkirk.     – check

So was BOOTH Fisheries and other locals

So was Stefanson Bros Fisheries

So were the commercial docks and still are

So is the Lift Bridge built 1934 still lifting

So is the train that ran to Gimli

So train the boats to get the fish to Winnipeg

We had fishing stations along the lake

We had the main gathering station and camp (on stilts)

We had Mouth of the Red River

We freighted to and fro

On to Winnipeg and Chicago.

On the paths of Gimli, Riverton

On they all did go, did and done.

Selkirk dock set the stage for the Lakes, the North

Filled the dock to and fro

Still do as for long as done.

Many waved good-byes to the Suzanne E

Never to hello again.

Stories of boats and builders of them Purvis’s led these crews right down the Red

Paddle-wheelers and Ships out to Pacific coast & ferry Big North Tukutuku too.

Net pullers, seeming-on Needles, Ice, fish processors, 60’s mercury restrictions

Quotas,1st nations twinned/paired with Icelandic ambitions.

Chuck the Cat Fish (look him way up) in vision treaties one treaties five.

                                     We joined

                                     We lived

                                      We survived.



Resources and Additional Information


Email us your questions or join the conversation on our Facebook Group.

bottom of page